A deadlocked vote Thursday in a key D.C. Council committee killed a bill that would have legalized autonomous vehicles in the District.
Council Chair Phil Mendelson called the result “embarrassing,” as lawmakers have studied AV deployment in D.C. — a city that has seen 37 traffic fatalities this year to date — for nearly 15 years.
“We are not the first city to be looking at this, and the committee print that we have has been so thoroughly vetted with all of the comments, testimony, issues that have been brought up,” said Mendelson at the markup, perched to the right of the committee chair and bill author, Ward 6 council member Charles Allen.
Those who voted “no” on the transportation committee — council members Zachary Parker, Elissa Silverman and Mayor-elect Janeese Lewis George — said they are not opposed to the technology, just the bill’s timing. They want to look into labor unions’ concerns about rideshare and taxi job displacement given the District’s record unemployment rates, coordinate with D.C. emergency management and public safety agencies and wait until the new mayor takes office.
Trending
Sign up for The Washington Sun Metro newsletter for essential coverage of the D.C. region.
“I want to make sure that our new mayor’s administration is given the opportunity to fully weigh in before we move forward,” said Silverman at the markup. “I just can’t believe you can put the genie back in the bottle.”
The sudden devolvement of the bill’s political prospects has frustrated its advocates, who argue that council members had years to debate the various merits and drawbacks of AV deployment. D.C. had one of the nation’s first AV testing laws on the books in 2012. Waymo, the nation’s largest AV operator, began testing here in 2024. In the last two and a half years, the council held three public hearings on how to get the rollout right — the most recent one, in July, lasted over ten hours.
“Council member Allen was the only one who stayed through that entire hearing,” said Greg Rogers, a former Waymo executive who is now executive director of The Innovation Majority, a nonprofit that advocates for transportation. “Why hadn’t they engaged before now on this issue?”
But the labor unions who helped kill the bill say that in all that time, they were never brought to the table. Jaime Contreras, the executive vice president of the local service workers union, said he wasn’t aware of the legislation until the summer, and only heard of it “through the grapevine.”
Once unions did learn of the bill, they mobilized against it, organizing a protest at the Wilson Building in early October and asking key council members to oppose it.
“Best case scenario for us is that they don’t allow them, period,” Contreras told The Washington Sun ahead of Thursday’s vote. “If I had it my way, that would be what would happen. These robots would never be allowed to come into our city.”
Their concerns bleed into broader ones about Big Tech and “robots” displacing human jobs across multiple industries. Of course, Big Tech has tried to weigh in on both sides of the AV debate.
Uber, in particular, has lobbied aggressively against D.C.’s AV legislation, putting the company in a strange alliance with the same unions who accuse them of exploiting drivers. The Washington Post found that Uber may be behind the mysterious coalition that poured more money into opposing AVs in D.C. than was spent on both mayoral campaigns this cycle.
Contreras doesn’t mind his strange bedfellows.
“Thank God for Uber and Lyft, then,” he said. “If they’re pushing for this, that means that they also care about human drivers. I’m not here to defend Uber or Lyft, but I think everybody should be freaked out that your job could be next.”
Allen was not surprised by Thursday’s outcome, telling reporters after the markup that he always knew the bill would face a tight committee vote.
But advocates for autonomous vehicles felt they were on fairly solid ground until the last few weeks. Waymo even spent tens of millions of dollars to build out three charging and maintenance facilities across D.C. in anticipation of regulatory approval and began hiring. Waymo declined to comment on what will happen to those facilities and jobs now that the bill has been delayed.
Then, in October, Lewis George publicly came out against legalizing AVs in D.C. for now, “given the anticipated AI-related job displacement and disruptions that put countless workers at risk.”
“That was a major turning point,” said Hope Ledford, director of civic innovation policy at the pro-AV Chamber of Progress. “We didn’t go into this campaign thinking ‘this is a slam dunk,’ we knew that there were going to be issues. … I don’t exactly know what’s happening behind closed doors with the council, but it’s been a disappointment to see, since the hearing this summer, how this unraveled.”
In the week before the hearing, things continued to “unravel.” Rumors swirled that Parker had flipped to a “no” vote, then that Silverman had, too. They confirmed as much to The Sun days ahead of the markup, and in an interview with WAMU, Silverman said Lewis George “came to [her] and said that she had reservations about Waymo,” expressly asking for “her new team to give their input” before moving forward with it.
“Let’s wait a few months, the Mayor-elect says this is a priority for her, and I’ll hold her to that,” Silverman told WAMU.
In a Hail Mary, Allen redrafted the bill to include major changes like giving rideshare drivers and AV facility workers collective bargaining rights, capping the total number of AVs at 800 across all companies and introducing a requirement that all operators ensure 20% of their fleet is wheelchair accessible by 2032. It wasn’t enough.
“Workers don’t need a fund. Workers need a fund in addition to good jobs,” Contreras said of the redrafted bill.
Wheelchair users who had opposed the bill for not requiring AV companies provide accessible rides were “excited” by Allen’s redraft, but still pushed council members to oppose it for now.
“What they have put in about accessibility is outstanding,” disability advocate Heidi Case told The Sun. “No one’s put a deadline on [wheelchair-accessible AVs] anywhere in the country. That’s huge. It’s exciting. We’re grateful about that … it’s a matter of timing.”
Some advocates, including Case, want another bill passed before this one to ensure equitable access to any new rideshare platforms coming into D.C. That other bill, which will be marked up Thursday, would require wheelchair-accessible rides arrive in no more than 110% of the average wait for standard rides, ban drivers from refusing service to disabled people and pay 10 cents per non-accessible ride for a fund that would purchase more accessible vehicles.
Case feels confident that Lewis George can pick this bill up in January and include the same “record breaking” accessibility provisions that Allen included in it. Allen, however, said it was a “real risk” that a new bill won’t have the same key labor and accessibility protections, and that a delay may allow neighboring states to anchor AV operation facilities.
“We’re going to see a lot more interest in AV companies putting their facilities outside D.C. if they know that D.C. is not open for business,” said Rogers. “That’s going to hurt District workers, and that’s going to hurt the ability of the District to capture this investment.”
Waymo declined to comment on whether it will now shift focus to Maryland and Virginia — where it’s already begun mapping — but did say last week that while it “remain[s] ready to work with the Council, postponing this debate delays the additional investments and jobs that come with scaling our operations.”
“On a somewhat deeper level,” Allen said during Thursday’s markup, with Lewis George nodding to his left. “I think this bill has, for better or worse, become an inflection point for a larger conversation around the future of the District.”