Secretary of Transportation Sean Duffy’s ballooning funding requests for the department’s air traffic control modernization efforts are raising questions within the government around the Department of Transportation’s budgeting practices.
Duffy requested $50 billion in additional funding for the efforts after a four-hour nationwide ground stop that threw the airline industry into turmoil last week. That was $20 billion more than a request Duffy and the Office of Management and Budget made in September — which caught lawmakers by surprise.
Republican and Democratic leaders have said they want answers first on currently unspent funds in the department’s coffers; specifically, the more than $5 billion for air traffic control modernization that remains unallocated from a $12.5 billion fund Congress gave the DOT last year.
“There’s some in the bill we did last year that hasn’t been used yet,” Senate Majority Leader John Thune said. “I think there’s about $8 billion left from that. We’re looking at what the needs are and doing that assessment.”
Trending
But Congress’ watchdog — which recently audited the agency’s air traffic control modernization efforts — says Duffy’s funding request is actually part of a bigger cost and planning issue surrounding the agency’s air traffic control modernization plans.
Congress has yet to receive a detailed cost assessment for the work Duffy plans to do and even some of the work underway already, said Kevin Walsh, a congressional auditor who led the Government Accountability Office’s recent review of the modernization effort. The DOT previously estimated to the GAO that it would need a little over $10 billion more to finish the second phase of its upgrade plan for the nation’s decaying air traffic control infrastructure.
“Normally you see an agency build up a cost estimate, and then they submit the request to Congress for ‘Hey, here’s how much money we think we’re going to need,’” Walsh said. “In this instance, it almost seems like it’s the reverse. They don’t have a formal estimate, but they’re asking anyway.”
In September, the GAO warned that the effort risks costing far more than previously anticipated. The $30 billion request from Duffy included $10 billion for airport infrastructure upgrades and $10 billion for new airport facilities like terminals and cargo expansion, projects that are not specifically related to air traffic control modernization. The final third was intended for the expected upgrades needed to the air traffic control system.
“We still maintain that having a cost estimate would be important for the taxpayers of the United States to know how much this modernization is going to cost,” Walsh said. His agency’s report warned that DOT’s estimates appeared to dramatically undercount the modernization costs.
Thune told reporters on Monday that Congress will have to take a look at unspent funds before determining how much additional funding to consider for the Federal Aviation Administration. Thune added that Congress has attempted “what we can” to fund the Trump administration’s concerns about modernization.
Senate Democratic Whip Dick Durbin, an appropriator, told reporters that Congress sent tens of millions of dollars to the administration to improve the system last year. He added that Duffy’s ask contained a “glaring error.”
“It’s an obvious question: Why aren’t you spending the money we sent to you?” Durbin said. “I think the problem is Russell Vought, who doesn’t want to see money spent on anything if he has his way.” Vought leads the OMB, which has restricted the $5 billion from being spent this fiscal year.
Senate Republican leadership also emphasized Durbin’s question. Sen. Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa) told The Washington Sun that he wants to hear an explanation from Duffy about those unspent funds. Duffy is set to eat lunch with Senate Republicans on Tuesday.
“Depends on whether they give us a good reason why they haven’t been spent yet,” Grassley said when asked if he would support appropriating more money. “Only $1 billion have been spent.”
Sen. James Lankford (R-Oklahoma) agreed, adding that he would like to see a clear purpose for those additional funds — especially while approved money remains unspent.
“They need to know what the next thing is,” Lankford said. “But if they’re focused on being able to get this updated, that’s been an issue for 20 years. … We passed $12.5 billion last year. We’re the first Congress to actually do something on air traffic control.”
The Department of Transportation brushed off allegations that the money had been frozen.
“The claim from congressional Democrats — who voted against this downpayment every step of the way — that OMB froze money is an absurd lie. They know better: OMB always apportions funds based on spending plans. The money is being used to upgrade the airspace at record pace,” said a Department of Transportation spokesperson who declined to be named. “Funds that haven’t been technically apportioned yet simply remain with OMB — exactly how the federal budget process has worked for decades.”
The OMB did not respond to request for comment. The $5 billion is currently labeled as apportioned for next fiscal year in the agency’s spending database, a label that the OMB frequently applies to pools of money that Congress appropriated but that the White House has not yet given the agency permission to spend.
The DOT provided a breakdown to The Sun that describes plans for the funding in the 2025 reconciliation bill. In the breakdown, the agency indicated that the unspent funds would be spent on new radar systems that have not yet been built, as well as on a facility consolidation effort that Congress mandated but that the agency does not view as a priority.
“Congress placed parameters on the funding outlining exactly how much of the total package could be spent on specific categories of work,” the agency spokesperson. “The Department does not have the legal flexibility to move funds from one workstream to another. As the Department has made clear for the last two years — separate funding is needed to cover separate work streams.”
The Transportation Department has been successful in speeding up the much-needed and previously slow-going efforts to update critical infrastructure, replacing wiring, radios and other systems at a much faster rate than any previous administration, the GAO report said. (Friday’s ground stop appeared to be caused by an issue with one such upgrade — replacing a router at an Arkansas facility.)
“Secretary Duffy and the Federal Aviation Administration have received historical and monumental investments over the last two years, over $12.5 billion of which was provided without meaningful guardrails or accountability requirements and largely remains unspent. No federal leader should be free to do their work without Congressional oversight,” said Rep. Rosa DeLauro (D-Connecticut), the ranking member on the House Appropriations Committee, in a statement.
The GAO could not persuade DOT to give it any detailed cost breakdowns for the second phase.
“Not enough funding, overly rosy estimates, all of those should be warning signs to anybody attempting this modernization,” Walsh said.