The Washington Sun

Main Navigation

Subscribe Log in
  • Newsletters
    • Sign up for our newsletters
    • The Washington Sun newsletter
    • Afternoon Sun
    • Metro
    • Sign up for Dana Milbank’s newsletter
    • Sign up for Matt K. Lewis’ newsletter
  • Weather
  • Campaigns
    • 2026 Election
    • 2028 Election
    • Democrats
    • Republicans
    • Influence
  • Congress
    • House
    • Senate
  • Metro
    • Latest in Metro
    • Tom Sietsema
  • Sports
    • Latest in Sports
    • All-DMV High School
  • Policy
    • Administration
    • Defense
    • Energy & Environment
    • Immigration
    • Economy
    • Health
    • Foreign Policy
    • Housing
    • Technology
  • National
    • Legal
    • U.S. News
  • Perspectives
    • Latest Perspectives
    • Dana Milbank
    • Matt K. Lewis
    • Features
    • Forums
  • Podcast
    • Washington Sun Cast • Episode List
    • Milbank & Lewis • Episode List
    • Listen on Apple Podcasts
    • Listen on Spotify
    • Watch on Youtube
  • Who Are We?
    • About The Washington Sun
    • Events
    • Work for us
    • Press Releases
    • Support FAQ
  • Follow Us
    • X (Twitter)
    • Bluesky
    • LinkedIn
    • Instagram
    • TikTok
    • YouTube
Subscribe
Log in

Support independent journalism. Subscribe for $50 for your first year. Limited time.

Legal

Judge Rejects DOJ’s Attempt to Limit Her Questions About ‘Broadview Six’ Scandal

The judge particularly wants to explore two comments made by prosecutors that she “now believes were inaccurate.”

Protesters gather outside an ICE processing facility in the Chicago suburb of Broadview, Illinois

The judge wants answers in a case against anti-ICE protesters. The DOJ is playing defense. (Nam Y. Huh/AP)

By Jose Pagliery

November 16, 2026 02:53 p.m.

  • Email
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • Copy
    Link copied

A federal judge in Chicago rejected on Monday the Justice Department’s push to limit what she asks prosecutors about their handling of the “Broadview Six” scandal — a case against anti-ICE protestors that collapsed amid signs of prosecutorial misconduct.

U.S. District Judge April Perry held a hearing that addressed the DOJ’s last-minute request Sunday that she not directly question the frontline career government prosecutors who worked on the case. Instead, the DOJ urged her to ask narrowly focused questions of the Trump-appointed political head of that office, U.S. Attorney Andrew Boutros.

What started with the appearance of a politically tainted case has led to revelations that prosecutors broke grand jury rules, resulting in a tanked case that was followed by recent accusations in a separate lawsuit from a former FBI supervisor that Attorney General Todd Blanche and FBI Director Kash Patel were involved.

The matter has become such a priority that Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward, the third highest ranking official at the DOJ, was in court Monday morning to monitor the government’s attempt to limit what has become the judge’s fact-finding mission.

Trending

  • U.S. Secretary of Agriculture Brooke L. Rollins,

    Trump Officials Carry Out an ‘Unprecedented’ Shakeup of USDA

  • A Bank of America branch.

    Bank Customers Are Struggling to Access Their Online Accounts

  • Rubio Jensen Huang

    Marco Rubio Snubbed Jensen Huang’s Outreach Before the Scandal Emerged

  • Police blocked off multiple blocks of 14th Street NW.

    What the Logan Circle Shooter Told Me

The judge wants answers. The DOJ is playing defense.

Henrique Carneiro, a counsel to the associate AG, wrote that ‘“here is plainly no need for anyone but the U.S. Attorney to provide information.” But he also made clear the government would fight the judge on appeal if she didn’t agree, arguing that she should essentially just let it go and allow the government to sort this out on its own.

“The correct approach would be to cease the inquiry and leave the matter ‘for the attorney general and the president to evaluate,’” Carneiro added.

However, Perry rejected the government’s request to label much of the information “privileged” and therefore inaccessible to the judge — and the American public, according to two people in the courtroom.

Former Democratic congressional candidate Kat Abughazaleh, who was among those charged, told The Washington Sun after the hearing that it “should be in the government’s interest to be as transparent as possible to prove it did no wrong.”

“At this point, I’m wondering what could be so horrible in these communications that the DOJ would go to such lengths to hide them,” Abughazaleh said.

Perry is planning to hold an evidentiary hearing, one that was initially supposed to take place Monday but has since been rescheduled for Dec. 2, to question Boutros and three other assistant U.S. attorneys. She particularly wants to explore two comments made by prosecutors that she “now believes were inaccurate.”

One relates to assistant U.S. Attorney William Hogan’s assurances in a March court filing that “there are no communications of any nature from, to, or with anyone outside the [Chicago U.S. Attorney’s Office] (other than the local FBI investigators assigned to the case) regarding any investigatory or charging decisions. To be crystal clear, this specifically includes anyone in the White House and all components and offices of Main Justice.”

The judge balked when Boutros’ office later provided a caveat that Hogan’s statement was “true as it relates to precharging decisions.” Boutros himself later revealed in a signed document Aug. 4 that, in fact, “there were discussions between the office and Main Justice regarding such things as case updates” — going further to point out that the “Supreme Court recently held” that “even the ‘president may discuss potential investigations and prosecutions with his attorney general.’”

The second apparent misstatement relates to how much Boutros actually knew about the three failed attempts to indict the protesters for “assaulting” federal agents — and former Assistant U.S. Attorney Sheri Mecklenburg taking the unusual step of dismissing jurors who expressed skepticism about the evidence and having private conversations with grand jurors in violation of rules expressly forbidding such interactions.

During a hearing in May, Boutros appeared in court on his own volition to volunteer that he was “completely unaware of any vouching that took place in the grand jury.” But he later clarified in a court filing that he had been emailed a copy of a grand jury transcript from one of the failed attempts, prompting the judge to note how odd it would be for the head of an office to not closely examine such a rare and stunning failure to secure an indictment in such a high-profile case as this one — especially when he would have had to authorize a second and even third attempt.

“Boutros’s statements are hard to credit,” Perry wrote on Nov. 2. “The idea that USA Boutros would have made such a significant decision without reviewing the best evidence available to him about what went wrong in the grand jury is nearly unfathomable.”

As the judge noted in her Nov. 2 order clarifying what she wanted to know from the government, the feds in April suddenly became “what can only be described as cagey about its communications with those outside” of the U.S. attorney’s office since April.

Michael Rabbitt, one of the Broadview Six co-defendants who is also the Democratic committeeperson for Chicago’s 45th Ward, told The Washington Sun he remains “optimistic” that the court case that upended his life is now “on the path to achieving accountability and justice.”

Rabbitt said defending himself from the failed prosecution has already cost him $375,000 in legal fees, which he’s only partly covered through $100,000 in donations and another $100,000 by drawing from the retirement accounts that belong to him and his wife.

“It’s stunning the extraordinary lengths the Trump DOJ is going to conceal their misconduct in this case. What they’re trying to cover up must be incredibly egregious,” he said.

Author

Jose Pagliery, NOTUS Reporter Jose Pagliery is a reporter at The Washington Sun.

The Latest

  • Union Station

    Amtrak Halts Service Around D.C., Citing ‘Local Municipal Officials’

  • Department of Education building

    Education Department Is Investigating a Washington State Trans Athlete Policy

  • Commanders AP - 26306173172397

    Commanders Midseason Report: Somehow, a Pathway to the Playoffs Still Exists

  • Protesters gather outside an ICE processing facility in the Chicago suburb of Broadview, Illinois

    Judge Rejects DOJ’s Attempt to Limit Her Questions About ‘Broadview Six’ Scandal

  • U.S. Park Police

    Park Police Officer Shoots a Person After a Car Chase

Welcome back to The Washington Sun!

You can always update your profile and newsletters preferences on the My Account page.

Manage account settings

Welcome to
The Washington Sun

Subscribe to maintain unlimited access to independent journalism covering Washington's people, politics and power.

Continue to checkout ↗
  • About The Washington Sun
  • Work for us
  • Terms of Use
  • Subscription Agreement Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Your CA Privacy Rights
  • Support FAQ
  • Contact us

© 2026.0 NOTUS MEDIA, LLC