The midterms are over, which means the 2028 presidential race is underway. Well, kind of. The Republican nomination calendar has yet to be set. Democrats have a calendar, but New Hampshire remains mad about it. But the seedlings of campaigns are everywhere for those who want to see them, and boy, do we want to see them. Candidates are out and about — going to dinners in early states and rolling up their literal sleeves on book covers — trying to win what we’re calling the vibes, that all-important momentum among the political class that polls don’t totally capture.
Welcome to the first monthly edition of the Vibes Index. We asked our panel of about 60 plugged-in politics watchers — reporters, pundits, Democratic and Republican campaign types and political scientists — to rank 10 candidates for each party’s nomination and candidates get points on how well they rank. Our panel weighed in on who’s up, who’s down and who’s delusional. We’ll return to our panel every month throughout the 2028 cycle, so check back in on the vibes.
Want to know more about what our panel of political cognoscenti had to say about the current field of buzzed-about names? Read here.
Democrats
Democrats are really feeling themselves after a midterm for the ages, everyone expects the list of potential presidential candidates to keep growing. After Democrats stumbled on potential national stars in seemingly every red state across the country, shadow 2028 campaigns that have been running for ages have found themselves crowded out by the new hotness. And we do mean hot.
Candidates get points based on how well they ranked. For context, we also show how they're doing in the polls (as of Nov. 15), their odds on the prediction markets (as of Nov. 14), and the attention they're getting on Wikipedia relative to their rivals (as of Nov. 14).
Jon Ossoff |
Polls9.3% Odds26% Wiki rank1 |
This wasn’t particularly close: Ossoff won more first-place votes than any other Democrat, by a long shot. This star has been rising for a while — back in June, we reported wannabe staff were lining up to work for a campaign that does not yet exist. The star has now gone supernova. Some of our panelists, however, suggest new fans take a cold shower: “Jon Ossoff, but I don't think he runs,” one plugged-in reporter wrote of their chosen vibes winner of the month. Indeed, Ossoff himself has said he will not run.
|
Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez |
Polls12.4% Odds15% Wiki rank3 |
While other candidates are scrounging around for a political base, AOC’s is at the ready. Still, you hear more plugged-in people talking about how she definitely won’t run than about how she eventually will. Do they know? Does anyone? |
Pete Buttigieg |
Polls12.5% Odds5% Wiki rank4 |
He didn’t run for anything in 2026, so he could run anywhere with everyone else. And so he did. People really wanted him around, and it’s no surprise: This guy is big famous now. “We love you, Pete!” a passerby yelled at him recently on a campaign stop in Mississippi. Next comes a book tour and all the other predictable steps.
|
Josh Shapiro |
Polls4.8% Odds5% Wiki rank7 |
This guy is now overseeing Pennsylvania’s first Democratic trifecta in, like, forever. The potential to turn rhetoric into splashy policy wins in a state one can presume will matter to national Democrats in 2028 is reason enough to not count him out. “Nailed a purple state midterm sweep!” one Democratic strategist said. So the bumper sticker is already written.
|
Gavin Newsom |
Polls13.5% Odds10% Wiki rank2 |
Newsom got literally everything he wanted this year — a successful redistricting gambit, a defeat of the lefty wealth tax, public fights with Trump, a truly bananas race to replace him that ended with a Democratic winner — and still he’s fifth, with only two first-place votes from our panel. Why? Because of all the recent success: “Newsom has the highest odds of uniting the various factions in the party.” one reporter said.
|
JB Pritzker |
Polls2.7% Odds2% Wiki rank6 |
Is it possible sixth place is exactly where Pritzker wants to be? As one political scientist put it, “The candidates drawing the most attention a year out from the start of the actual primary season are in the most danger — of an undiscovered liability in the past, of saying something stupid.” Meanwhile, the billionaire Illinois governor can assemble his campaign out of the spotlight and throw a lot of money at candidates and causes too.
|
Wes Moore |
Polls1.4% Odds2% Wiki rank10 |
It was hard for him to get a word in edgewise this year. He had a failed redistricting fight that tarnished him a bit in the spring, and then his own reelection campaign to run. Which he did — winning by more than 30 points. It’s easy to relaunch oneself after that, which he is about to do with a book about fixing America.
|
Andy Beshear |
Polls2.9% Odds4% Wiki rank8 |
What did the midterms mean for him in the end? He chaired the Democratic Governors Association, which won a lot of governorships this year. “I think it becomes easier for Beshear to craft a winning message into 2028,” one reporter said. But also, he chaired the Democratic Governors Association, which pissed off a lot of people this year. “Not getting involved in the Texas gov” is a big problem, one Democratic pundit fumed.
|
Mark Kelly |
Polls7.0% Odds3% Wiki rank9 |
The former Navy pilot and astronaut can read a map, and Democrats have drawn one just for him. Early nominating states like New Mexico are in his neck of the
|
Kamala Harris |
Polls22.0% Odds5% Wiki rank5 |
Obviously the former VP drew huge crowds on the trail, has mega name ID among the Democratic electorate and, oh yeah, lost in 2024. Early polls show she’s doing just fine, but basically no one thinks she has the rizz. “Bench of newcomers looks a lot more appealing than being reminded of their 2024 defeat,” one pundit said. “She was on the outside of this enormous victory,” a political scientist said.
|
Others receiving votes: James Talarico (30 ballots), Cory Booker (22), Gretchen Whitmer (17), Amy Klobuchar (10), Chris Murphy (9)
Republicans
Remember these guys? Republicans do still exist after the midterm shellacking, and their 2028 field just became the more interesting one. This party has been in this wilderness before: humiliated by a weak and divided opposition party, with no obvious next move. Out of those ashes the last time came an unlikely savior: Donald Trump. But now he’s the problem, and the solution is anyone’s guess. There’s no clear-cut vibes leader in this group like there is with the Dems. But there is a guy who has already proved he’s willing to do any job.
Marco Rubio |
Polls25.5% Odds17% Wiki rank5 |
Rubio wears a lot of hats in his day job(s), and everyone sees a version of him that they like. He’s “above the fray of the infighting,” said one reporter especially plugged in to Trumpworld. Theoretically, his close ties to the unpopular president would be a problem, but “reports of MAGA's death have been greatly exaggerated,” another reporter put it.
|
Ron DeSantis |
Polls9.0% Odds15% Wiki rank3 |
He only got seven first-place votes, but that’s enough for DeSantis to land in second place. “Florida was a lonely exception to the GOP wipeout in the midterms, which vaults DeSantis into contention,” one columnist said. But there may be more to it, too: “He is meeting the zeitgeist of the party right now,” a reporter said. Has the time for I told you so vibes arrived for Republicans?
|
JD Vance |
Polls37.0% Odds35% Wiki rank2 |
Vance won the second-highest total of first-place votes BUT he also was ranked as having the worst month by many of our panelists. “Vance is #1 because he’s the VP,” one think tanker said. This same person said Vance also had the worst month of any Republican candidate, you know, because he’s the VP. He has everything he needs to win the nomination except a record of persuading his boss not to go to war with Iran.
|
Ted Cruz |
Polls2.8% Odds3% Wiki rank4 |
On the one hand, he did tell the truth that Republicans could lose every statewide office in Texas. On the other hand, they did in fact lose them. Now Cruz is the last statewide elected Republican in Texas. Whoops! “Cruz has essentially lost the ability to run for president in 2028, because his replacement would be appointed by a Democrat,” one data cruncher noted. (It’s slightly more complicated than that, but certainly not a good spot for him.)
|
Glenn Youngkin |
Polls1.1% Odds3% Wiki rank10 |
If the GOP fractures again after MAGA, Youngkin can absolutely find a base in the wreckage. But it may not be at home: Virginia is very blue after DOGE, and it started getting bluer because of him. He wants to be the Romneyier Trump, but he may be the Trumpier Romney.
|
Josh Hawley |
Polls1.9% Odds1% Wiki rank9 |
Hey, the first relatively new name on the list! This is a good place to be. Republicans have a lot of sorting to do, and if the primaries get crazy, there’s room for a guy seen as an outsider with a populist bent to rise. A populist streak in the incoming Democratic Senate could give him a chance to notch some bipartisan wins, too.
|
Tucker Carlson |
Polls2.0% Odds4% Wiki rank8 |
Hard to argue with it: “Tucker was right about the major issues in the midterms — Israel, AI, the war, etc. And he still hates immigrants and so the America Firsters love that. Like he actually is doing the America First thing still,” one journalist said. But also: He can do all of that without having to step out from behind his podcast mic and ask voters for their actual opinion of him. |
Sarah Huckabee Sanders |
Polls1.3% Odds1% Wiki rank7 |
Our panelists had almost nothing to say about her but ranked her above veteran candidates such as Nikki Haley anyway. She has won elections, can speak MAGA and has a record. Oh, and she has a book tour coming up.
|
Byron Donalds |
Polls— Odds1% Wiki rank1 |
Donalds recently became a big deal, but maybe too recently for anyone to think about the next thing. He now has the chance to notch legislative wins and be a Republican in charge of something when so many others aren’t. Unfortunately for him, DeSantis has a head start.
|
Nikki Haley |
Polls3.5% Odds1% Wiki rank6 |
A view through rose-colored glasses may see her as the last candidate standing against Trump in the 2024 primaries, but really she didn’t stand for very long. She’s had a lot of opportunities to say something these past couple of years, but didn’t.
|
Others receiving votes: Donald Trump Jr. (30 ballots), Robert F. Kennedy Jr. (27), Tim Scott (24), Rand Paul (21), Greg Abbott (6)
How we did this
Our scoring system for our 60-odd panelists resembles the AP poll for college football: They rank their top 10 candidates for each party, and the top vote-getter gets 10 points, the second gets 9, and so on.
We excluded candidates who are constitutionally ineligible to be president, either because they have already served two full terms or because they weren’t born in the U.S.
Voters are anonymous, though participants are free to share their votes themselves. To apply to participate, hit up vibesindex@washingtonsun.com.
Arrows compare each candidate’s rank with the previous release. This is the first edition of the board, so there are none yet.
Sources
Polling data has been aggregated and shared for free by our friends at The New York Times.
Polls have been weighted based on pollster grades from Silver Bulletin and, in a few cases, VoteHub.
Wikipedia traffic includes each candidate’s main entry, plus any redirects that send the page substantial additional visitors.
Prediction-market data is a composite of Kalshi and Polymarket.