With the prospect of a baseball work stoppage looming, the sport would be wise to avoid a
repeat of the aftermath of the 1981 strike, when the league’s owners came up with a plan that was too clever by half.
Following that seven-week strike, Major League Baseball adopted a split season, declaring the teams that led their divisions at the beginning of the strike on June 12 the first-half winners. They would face off in a best-of-five playoff against the team that won the division in the second half.
It led to the odd outcome of the Cincinnati Reds missing the playoffs despite having the best overall record in baseball (they finished second in their division in both halves). Worse, some managers found a fatal flaw with the plan: it could incentivize teams to lose games on purpose down the stretch to boost their chances of making the playoffs. MLB had to quickly come up with a patch to close this loophole.
Trending
Sign up for The Washington Sun Metro newsletter for essential coverage of the D.C. region.
Owners voted for the split season plan on Aug. 6, 1981, hoping the expanded playoff pool — years before MLB added wild card teams — would help boost interest in the pennant races in the face of widespread fan disenchantment.
“I favored the split season because I thought it put some marketing spice into the balance of
the schedule,” commissioner Bowie Kuhn wrote in his autobiography.
But not everyone was enamored with the idea.
“The entire concept is so stupid I can’t believe we’re going to ask the American public to buy it,” said Whitey Herzog, manager and GM of the St. Louis Cardinals.
Under the plan, if a team won both halves, it would play the team with the second-best overall record in the division. But an up-and-coming manager, 36-year-old Chicago White Sox skipper Tony La Russa, figured out that it opened the door to a team losing on purpose to make the playoffs.
In this hypothetical, the White Sox — who finished just two and a half games behind the Oakland A’s in the first half and nine and a half games ahead of the Kansas City Royals in the American League West — could be motivated to lose a four-games series to Oakland in the final week of the season. That’s because the Royals, the defending AL champs, had the best shot at displacing the A’s as division winners in the second half. By losing to the A’s, the White Sox could help them win both halves, allowing the Sox to sneak into the playoffs with the second-best overall record.
La Russa said he’d forfeit those games if it would help his team make the playoffs.
“It’s clear to me that nobody is going to take care of us except ourselves,” he told the Chicago Tribune at the time.
Herzog suggested he’d also be willing to lose games to boost the Cardinals’ chances.
“I’ll activate myself — I’d be the catcher and I’d have players throw with the other hand,” he said. “The commissioner won’t like me for saying that, but I didn’t want this anyway. To lose would be the right thing to do.”
In a recent phone interview, La Russa recalled meeting with his coaching staff to strategize about the second half. “I just remember looking at the numbers and trying to figure out how we could get in.” He soon realized that “you literally could lose a game on purpose and get into the playoffs.” After he made his comments to the press, Kuhn summoned him to a meeting at the commissioner’s office.
“I sat in Mr. Kuhn’s office and explained it, and he didn’t deny it,” La Russa said. “He didn’t reprimand me. He just said that he’s glad that I called it to his attention.”
Kuhn was quick to acknowledge the problem.
“It’s theoretically possible for a team to lose in order to get into the playoffs,” he said.
MLB quickly approved a fix, calling for the team with the second-best record in the second half to qualify — not the second-best overall record — if a team won both halves.
Today, players and owners are staring at a 2027 abyss because of the owners’ insistence on a salary cap, which is anathema to the players union. Back in ’81, the battle was a bit different — focused mostly on how much compensation a team should get for losing a free agent — but it was fundamentally about the same thing: owners’ desire to control ever-increasing player salaries.
Free agency was relatively new at the time — it had been just a few years since an arbitrator’s December 1975 ruling declared two pitchers free agents in a landmark test case. The ’81 strike was the first long work stoppage after several small skirmishes in the ’70s, and appeared to steel the players going forward.
“I very seriously doubt that the owners will try to challenge the players again,” said Orioles third baseman Doug DeCinces, who served on the players’ negotiating committee.
It also soured many fans on baseball.
“What Watergate was to the presidency, the 1981 strike was to baseball,” Tom Verducci wrote
in a 2020 Sports Illustrated story. “Never again would we look at either institution with the
same amount of faith. Baseball in 1981 returned to cold shoulders, protests and resentment.”
MLB resumed its season with the All-Star Game in Cleveland on Aug. 9 after an ad hoc and ridiculously short training camp of eight days.
On one level, baseball-starved fans demonstrated a lot of enthusiasm at the return of the national pastime, with an All-Star Game record crowd of 72,086 fans packing Cleveland Stadium, and Vice President George H.W. Bush threw out the first pitch. But many participated in a “blow the whistle” protest, featuring 10,000 fans whistling a primal scream of outrage at the start of every half-inning.
Meanwhile, the expanded playoffs saw some new entrants. The Montreal Expos made their
first postseason appearance after winning the NL East’s second-half title, then beat the
defending champion Phillies to advance to the National League Championship Series, where they lost to the Dodgers. It would be the only time the franchise made the playoffs during its time in Montreal.
In the American League, the Milwaukee Brewers made the playoffs for the first time by winning the second-half East title, but lost to the Yankees in the divisional round. New York beat the A’s to win the AL pennant, before losing the World Series to the Dodgers. (Yes, them again.)
But the real story of that season was how the Reds had an MLB-best .611 winning percentage, yet had nothing to show for it. In the first half, they finished just a half game behind the Dodgers in the NL West, who played one extra game. In the second half, Cincinnati came in second place to the Houston Astros.
The St. Louis Cardinals experienced a similar fate — a combined .578 winning percentage, best in the NL East, but spread out over a pair of second-half finishes, including an excruciating second half when they were just half a game behind the Expos, who won by a whisker thanks to an extra game. It’s no wonder Herzog thought the plan was stupid.
Frederic J. Frommer, a sports and politics historian who has written for The Washington Post, The New York Times, the Atlantic and other national publications, is working on a book on ’70s baseball.