Time is, one hopes, ticking down on Trumpism. And just as potential Republican presidential candidates are jockeying for position, so are the intellectuals and pundits who hope to sway the direction of the country in 2028 and beyond.
That’s the backdrop for a heated battle among Never Trump conservatives that broke out over the past few days. It all started last week in Denver, where Democratic leaders had gathered for a post-midterms conference called “What’s Next.” Among the speakers was Sarah Longwell, publisher of The Bulwark. “You may know us,” she declared to the audience. “We’re the Never Trumpers. At least we were 10 years ago. Now we’re just kind of libs just like the rest of you.”
For a lot of Republicans, this was a long-awaited admission: Longwell, and by extension the publication she helps run, seemed to be conceding that she had abandoned her erstwhile conservative positions and was openly embracing liberalism and the Democratic Party.
Jonah Goldberg, co-founder of The Dispatch, another Trump-skeptical publication, denounced Longwell on X, writing: “Always Trump and Never Trump became two sides of the same coin.” Longwell’s Bulwark colleague Tim Miller fired back, accusing Goldberg of moral equivalence. For her part, Longwell equated “anti-anti Trumpers and far leftists” because both groups spend “their energy shitting on normie dems.” Goldberg then replied with a longer missive suggesting ulterior motives: that The Bulwark is rebranding because its “current orientation is evaporating as we’re reaching the end of the Trump era.”
There were multiple things at play here. Part of the schism was about the time-honored disconnect between, on the one hand, journalists and intellectuals and, on the other, operatives and activists. “You’re a political operative,” Goldberg told Longwell. “You think, like a political operative, that you should say or do what’s necessary for your team to win. … I’m neither a political operative nor party hack.”
But the more interesting disagreement is about two different visions of how to move past Trump: one that largely seeks to restore conservatism to what it was before 2016 and one that implies conservatives have to reevaluate everything about their philosophy after the Trump years.
Let’s start with the former. If your hope is to restore pre-Trump conservatism, then it’s vital that you retain some relationships and bonafides within the movement and its longstanding political vessel, the Republican Party. The Goldberg point of view emerges from this ideological framework. Conservatives from this wing of the Never Trump world are deeply committed to a Reaganite philosophy and see Trump as an illegitimate interloper. And they resent a publication like The Bulwark that is still using its conservative credentials (when convenient) while arguably having moved into complete solidarity with the Democratic Party.
The other view — the one that seems to be Longwell’s — is that today’s MAGA GOP is simply too corrupted and co-opted to be saved. If you believe this, then maybe Democratic red-state “normies” — the kinds of people who voted for James Talarico, Adam Hamilton or Rob Sand — really are more fertile ground than the GOP for some of the principles that used to animate conservatism.
Implicit in this view is a sense that maybe the pre-Trump GOP was broken all along, even if some conservatives couldn’t see it at the time. The Bulwark’s Mona Charen once captured this idea with a striking metaphor about the rise of Trump. “Someone said it’s like finding out that your spouse has been unfaithful or a friend has betrayed you. Suddenly you look back at the entire relationship with a jaundiced eye, interpreting everything differently,” she wrote. “It has forced me to reconsider ideas that may have become calcified and opened me to people and perspectives I would previously have dismissed.”
As a committed Never Trumper, I casually know and like both Longwell and Goldberg; I’m also a fan of The Bulwark and The Dispatch. As such, I find myself with some sympathy for both sides of this debate. You can respect folks who plant a flag and stick with an enduring philosophy (Goldberg) even in the midst of storms and turmoil. But you can also respect people (Longwell) who acknowledge that the times have changed — and, along the way, so have they.
Whatever you think of their respective positions, it seems clear that these two individuals and their outlets are a microcosm of a larger divide between conservatives who broke with Trump. Basically, every Never Trump conservative in America, to some degree, falls into one of these camps. Some can’t imagine joining the Democratic Party. Others can’t imagine re-joining the GOP. Both have their reasons.
And, I would argue, the split isn’t a bad thing at all. Just for fun, imagine this situation is a giant conspiracy to reinvigorate old-school conservatism. It would make perfect sense to leave behind a remnant to bide its time and try to push the GOP back toward being a saner, more decent, more philosophically coherent party. Simultaneously, it would make perfect sense to infiltrate the Democratic Party. To push back against the DSA types. To elect Democrats who live in red states, who go to church, who are at least personally pro-life. To make the Democrats a more centrist party again.
Mind you, I’m not suggesting that this actually is some grand conspiracy. I’m simply pointing out that diversification is a pretty shrewd idea. That Longwell and Goldberg shouldn’t be at each other’s throats. That they might consider viewing each other not as adversaries but as allies working opposite corners of the same street.
Just as Barnabas and the Apostle Paul decided to part company, Goldberg and Longwell are now doubling the amount of ground they can cover. This is something for conservatives to celebrate, not fight about.
Matt K. Lewis is a Washington Sun Perspectives columnist.
To get the latest columns from Matt — a center-right voice who puts intellectual honesty above partisan hackery — sign up here.
More Perspectives:
Juleanna Glover: Let the Subpoenas Fly But Target Actual Crimes That Can Be Prosecuted
The Key Overlooked Trend of the Midterms: Democrats Finally Made Themselves More Local
Forum: Sen. Bill Cassidy, Rep. Nancy Mace and Seven Other Republicans on How to Fix Their Party