Now that Democrats have won majorities in the House and Senate, they are making lots of noise about the investigations to come. Democratic Rep. Analilia Mejia of New Jersey promised “to toss out subpoenas like Mardi Gras beads,” while Democratic Sen. Ed Markey of Massachusetts quipped, “They are going to need to plant new forests for all of the subpoenas we’ll be printing.”
Democrats are indeed in a strong position to launch wide-ranging investigations. In the House, the incoming Democratic chairs of the Judiciary, Oversight and Administration committees will be able to issue subpoenas on a party-line basis. In the Senate, the chair of the Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations will be able to do the same.
It’s an enormous amount of power. But to use it effectively, Democrats must distinguish between grandstanding (largely pointless) and uncovering crimes that can be prosecuted (sorely needed). They should adopt a tightly focused, pragmatic strategy — one that has the maximum odds of serving justice.
Democrats will surely be tempted to go after CEOs who gave money to various nonprofits affiliated with President Donald Trump, such as the inaugural committee, the presidential library and the fund supporting the White House ballroom. But while the behavior of these CEOs may have been cynical — craven even — it almost certainly wasn’t illegal.
Major corporations have the best lawyers in the world. Their political giving will have been screened for compliance with U.S. and state law. CEOs knew all along that when Democrats someday got subpoena power, they would be potential targets for congressional investigation — and most presumably will have conducted themselves as such. Yes, there’s always the possibility that some corporate knucklehead may have emailed something that could prove a bribery charge. But I wouldn’t bet on it.
I’m not a neutral observer on these matters, to be transparent. I advise corporations that have relationships with the Trump administration. But I also believe the administration has engaged in egregious and illegal behavior since coming to office, and that behavior ought to be brought to light and prosecuted. My argument here is that if Democrats spend their time going after any and all corporate executives who have done business in Trump’s D.C., they are going to waste an important window of opportunity.
What Democrats should do instead is focus on finding plausible evidence of real wrongdoing — say, around no-bid contracts to renovate the Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool or to build the ballroom, or the billions in defense contracts that have gone to companies affiliated with the Trump family. I can’t help wondering if some Trump insiders might have been messy in their communications around wagers placed on betting apps, crypto schemes and the various investments and partnerships tied to those who are close to the president and other administration officials.
And if Democrats want to get results, they will have to further narrow which cases they pursue. Historically, when congressional committees uncover evidence of crimes, they make a criminal referral to the Department of Justice, which decides whether to move forward with an investigation or not. We can presume that under Trump’s DOJ any criminal referral will be a dead letter. We also should assume that Trump will offer a pardon to anyone who wants one before he leaves office.
Fortunately, an end-run is available: Congressional Democrats can focus their investigative efforts on cases where there is specific legal nexus with states that have Democratic attorneys general — who can, in turn, build and prosecute corruption cases based on the subpoenaed evidence and sworn testimony uncovered from congressional hearings. Congress can lay breadcrumbs for state prosecutors to follow.
Democrats need to move quickly. They have to uncover compelling examples of prosecutable corruption and refer those cases to blue AGs before they get deep into a presidential primary fight. Subpoena power emanating from congressional committees is a time-limited and vital resource. If they pursue the path of grandstanding, they will be wasting both time and political capital. And not only that: They will also be creating dozens of influential Democrat-hating mini-Musks throughout the business world.
It might be emotionally satisfying to Democrats to berate the biggest-name CEOs on a national stage. But I don’t think this performative approach, ultimately, will result in much more than some social media clips. Democrats should go after those who most likely broke the law and only where the crimes can be linked to states that might pursue prosecutions. The rest will accomplish little, for either taxpayers or justice.
Juleanna Glover is the CEO of Ridgely Walsh, a corporate consultancy.
More Perspectives:
The Key Overlooked Trend of the Midterms: Democrats Finally Made Themselves More Local
Forum: Sen. Bill Cassidy, Rep. Nancy Mace and Seven Other Republicans on How to Fix Their Party
Milbank & Lewis Podcast: Are the Democrats in Disarray — Already?