A bill that would have introduced a 10-cent refundable deposit for bottles and cans won’t be advancing in the D.C. Council this year, after it was hammered for 18 months by large beverage distributors, a growing number of small neighborhood retailers and even the city’s homegrown beer brewers.
Multiple people told The Washington Sun that the bill — first introduced by Ward 1 Council member Brianne Nadeau in January 2025 — was facing uncertain prospects in the council, where lawmakers are rushing to close out the two-year legislative cycle but have grown more concerned about any measure that could be seen as increasing costs or regulatory demands for local businesses, especially as D.C.’s economy slows in the wake of sweeping federal layoffs.
“I’m still confident that it’s going to move forward in the future,” Nadeau told The Sun in an interview Friday morning. “I obviously would love to have been here for its victory. But it’s a really complex piece of legislation. And I have really thoughtful colleagues who like to work through all the various parts of a piece of legislation before they’re ready to support it.”
The bill’s demise is a loss for Nadeau, who isn’t returning to the council next year and had aggressively pushed the bottle-deposit bill as a legacy project to cap her 12 years in office. It’s also a disappointment for D.C. environmental groups, who passionately argued that the bill would help spur recycling and thus clean up the Anacostia River — largely to the benefit of low-income and majority-Black neighborhoods on the east side of its banks.
Trending
“Legislation like this often takes a few tries. But we’ve made a ton of progress. So I think it’s really positive,” said Nadeau.
The biggest winner may be the American Beverage Association, which funded a years-long multimillion-dollar local campaign against the bill under the guise of the Alliance for an Affordable D.C. The alliance also defeated an earlier effort by Nadeau to impose a new tax on sodas and sugary drinks in the city. The beverage industry is now two-for-two on killing bottle-deposit proposals in D.C.; almost 40 years ago it rallied to help defeat a ballot initiative that would have imposed a 5- to 20-cent deposit on bottles and cans.
“It wasn’t a surprise to me that some of the biggest polluters that we have here didn’t want to have to pay to clean up their trash, which is really what this does,” Nadeau said. “It puts the onus back on these companies to get the containers back and to incent residents to do so.”
When Nadeau first introduced the bill, she was backed by a broad coalition of environmental and civic groups, as well as 10 of her colleagues. She said bringing a refundable bottle-deposit to D.C. — 10 states currently have bottle-bill laws — would help clean up the Anacostia River, where some 60% of the weight of the trash retrieved is made up of plastic bottles, by giving people a financial incentive to return cans and bottles.
Every consumer would pay 10 cents per bottle or can when buying a beverage and get that money back upon return of the container. The bill would have required drink distributors to pay fees to help fund a beverage stewardship organization, which would set up redemption locations for bottles and cans across D.C.
Proponents said recycling rates for bottles and cans, now hovering around 25%, would increase dramatically, keeping trash off the streets and out of the rivers. It would also offer an opportunity for people to make money by collecting bottles and cans.
Still, opponents big and small hammered the proposal. Local beer brewers worried that new packaging and canning would add costs they couldn’t bear. Some faith leaders in Wards 5, 7 and 8 argued that redemption centers would likely end up in their neighborhoods. And the Alliance for an Affordable D.C. organized hundreds of small retailers and restaurants against the bill; earlier this week, the group sent a letter to the council making a final plea for lawmakers not to advance it.
“The bottle bill is especially bad for our businesses. The bill would add an additional cost to bars, restaurants, hotels, hospitals and any establishment where beverages are sold in bottles and cans. We would pay more for every bottle and can that we put on our shelves. That money comes from somewhere and it will impact our bottom line,” the letter said.
Bill supporters pushed back on many of those claims, pointing out that prices for beverages in states that currently have bottle-deposit bills are in most cases no different from those that don’t have them. They also criticized the beverage association’s big spending against the bill — estimated at more than $2 million — and said they resorted to unfounded scare tactics.
“It’s no surprise they’re spending so much against this bill – and it’s not because they’re worried about consumers. They know that bottle bills work, and they, the polluters, will be forced to pay and be responsible for their own pollution,” said Susan Schorr, co-chair of the Zero Waste Committee of the District of Columbia Chapter of the Sierra Club, in an October email. “They will say all sorts of things to try to defeat this bill, but in the end it seems they just care about their own profits.”
The council’s last two legislative sessions take place in December, after which Nadeau will be replaced by Council member-elect Aparna Raj, a progressive. Other progressives will also be joining the legislature, opening the door for a similar bill to be revived at some point.