Democrats have said they plan to claw back Congress’ authority over trade policy and pressure President Donald Trump to reverse his tariff agenda. They risk losing some of their biggest political allies in the process.
Unions representing steelworkers, autoworkers and other manufacturing employees have been insulated from global competitors due to some of Trump’s high tariffs on imported steel, aluminum, cars and industrial materials. Those protections could be in jeopardy as Democrats discuss broad tariff rollbacks to deliver on their campaign promises of lowering prices.
“If they go after statutes that force the unions to defend their workers and our members, and quite frankly, both union and non-union workers, it will lead to a nonproductive conversation,” said United Steelworkers legislative director Roy Houseman.
The top Democrat on the Ways and Means Committee, Rep. Richard Neal (D-Massachusetts), told The Washington Sun that Congress must reassert its tariff powers to ensure the consistency and legality of tariff application.
Trending
“We want to make sure that for affected industries they are targeted, but not to miss the point that the way they’ve been done with this administration, they’re just selectively applied and they’re done in a punitive manner,” Neal said.
Sen. Ron Wyden (D-Oregon), who is expected to be the next chair of the Senate Finance Committee, which oversees tariffs, has long argued the levies raise consumer prices. Wyden introduced a bill in July requiring the president to obtain Congress’ approval before imposing tariffs and led a letter to the Commerce Department last year accusing the Trump administration of misusing the national security tariff authority to shape industry.
Wyden declined to comment when asked about Democrats and unions taking different positions on tariffs. But unions say they are keeping a close eye.
“[Sen. Wyden is] going to have to balance the needs of senators whose states have impacts related to global excess capacity and steel and other key commodities, the ability to balance those impacts with the very real need to address the ability of U.S. producers to make a profit,” Houseman said.
Democrats have introduced legislation to repeal the nearly century-old Section 338 of the Tariff Act of 1930, which Trump has used to levy 50% tariffs on Canadian goods, and rein in the president’s tariff powers. At issue for unions like USW is the Section 232 tariff authority, which allows tariffs on the basis of national security, and Section 301 tariffs related to trade relationships with countries pursuing unfair practices, including forced labor. Democrats have argued these tariff authorities are applied too broadly.
Unions’ stances on tariff policy run the gamut. Even heavy manufacturing unions want to throw out tariffs that punish Canada, where they often represent workers, while keeping certain protective tariffs in place.
For example, the International Association of Machinists and Aerospace Workers, which represents nearly 600,000 workers, supports imposing Section 301 tariffs against predatory trade practices in Chinese shipbuilding and repealing tariffs on fair trading partners.
“We look forward to working with the incoming Congress to help construct trade policy in a manner that improves affordability while still ensuring that bad trade actors are made to pay for their actions,” IAM Union International President Brian Bryant said in a statement.
Democrats latched onto tariffs early into Trump’s second term as a clear-cut target for future policymaking on affordability concerns. Lawmakers in the new majority have said there’s room for negotiating tariffs to protect key industries, even as they pursue an overhaul on trade policy in the name of fairness and predictability lacking under the Trump administration.
“We need to find a way to lower costs for Americans, and the tariffs are one of the big drivers,” said Rep. Jim McGovern (D-Massachusetts). “Doesn’t mean all tariffs are bad or are unwarranted, but it means that what this administration has done has caused an economic crisis for working families.”
Sen. Raphael Warnock (D-Georgia), who leads Democrats on the Senate Finance trade subcommittee, also attempted to walk a fine line: “Tariffs can play a role in our policy. The problem is we don’t have a rational tariff policy. This across the board tariffs doesn’t work,” he said.
Trump’s mercurial tariff policy has fomented uncertainty among businesses attempting to plan their balance sheets. At the same time, tariffs have raised prices for consumers facing yearslong post-pandemic inflation exacerbated by the Iran war.
Organized labor wants to prevent tariffs from becoming the predominant policy area in Democrats’ affordability agenda and messaging.
“What the labor movement would like to see is more of a balanced approach on how we’re dealing with economic issues — the kitchen table, bread and butter issues, and of course, trade policy plays a factor in that,” said Liz Shuler, the president of the AFL-CIO, whose member unions represent nearly 15 million workers.
“It’s got to be more of a holistic discussion, and just plucking out trade policy is to me not as much a cohesive approach to what we’d like to see,” Shuler added.