A federal judge ordered The Greenbrier Resort, partially owned by the family of West Virginia Sen. Jim Justice, to repay $35 million in Main Street Lending Program funding, plus $17 million in interest, for defaulting on the loan.
The ruling on the unpaid pandemic loan is another chapter in the Justice family’s nearly 20-year ownership of the storied resort, which has also been mired in what the billionaire lawmaker recently described as “a highly complex legal dispute” over the resort’s future.
In this case, the loan was provided by First Guaranty Bank in Louisiana and chaired by businessman Marshall T. Reynolds, a Huntington, West Virginia, native. First Guaranty sued over the loan, which had been delinquent since December 2023, in a case that began in Louisiana before moving to the Southern District of West Virginia.
The judge, in an opinion Thursday, said there was no question Greenbrier defaulted and rejected the resort’s arguments why judgment should not be entered now.
Trending
The Greenbrier didn’t dispute that it missed payment, but contended the bank unfairly rejected a February 2025 proposal to push full repayment to the end of 2026, the opinion says.
The bank’s CEO testified that the Federal Reserve turned down the request by phone, although that was never put in writing, and nothing in the loan documents required the bank to agree to the proposal to extend the repayment date, the judge wrote.
Justice purchased the then-struggling historic resort in 2009, and handed day-to-day control to his daughter Jill when elected governor of West Virginia in 2016. Since the purchase, the resort has struggled with increasing debt. In late March 2026, the Rowling family, which owns Omni Hotels, paid $289 million to pay off the resort’s first-lien debt.
The Justices sued, alleging Carter Bank and TRT Holdings, the parent company of Omni Hotels and Resorts, conspired to force them out. Omni’s subsidiary asked a federal court to appoint a receiver.
Earlier this year, the Justices announced an agreement with Kennedy Lewis Investment Management in an effort to bring financial stability to the resort, which ended the feud with Omni. The firm took 51% ownership of the resort company for a reported $500 million, leaving the Justice family with 49%.
The Greenbrier Resort, Kennedy Lewis Investment Management and the Justice family did not immediately return The Washington Sun’s inquiries.
A Government Accountability Office report in June found that 70% of the Main Street program’s loans had been fully repaid. The initiative was established in the CARES Act and was one of 13 emergency lending programs in response to COVID-19. The loans were supposed to be paid back by early January 2026.
The resort itself is over 100 years old, and sits on 11,000 acres of land in southern West Virginia. The resort also housed an underground emergency shelter for the United States Congress built during the Cold War before it was decommissioned after The Washington Post exposed it in 1992.