A federal judge blocked Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins from sending department-wide religious emails, ruling that sending such messages likely violated the Constitution and created “coercive pressure” for employees.
On Thursday, U.S. District Judge Trina Thompson ordered Rollins to “recognize certain boundaries when disseminating messages which convey religious content” — a directive that includes heeding employees’ requests to not send such communications and ensuring she does not create a “hostile work environment through persistent unwelcome advances.”
Under the preliminary injunction, Rollins may continue to discuss her faith only with “interested colleagues” and in “appropriate conversations,” Thompson, a Joe Biden appointee, ruled.
Rollins, a practicing Christian, sent USDA staffers a series of messages last year that made faith-based references to a “loving God” and “his Son and our Savior Jesus Christ.”
Trending
The plaintiffs, a group of six USDA employees and the National Federation of Federal Employees, filed a lawsuit in May, arguing that they are expected to read all communications from the secretary because the emails could contain important workplace information. Employees urged the court last month to act before the upcoming Christmas holiday.
The First Amendment’s Establishment Clause prohibits the government from taking actions that would promote or institute one religion over another. The Supreme Court has ruled against other faith-based expressions in public institutions, such as the display of the Ten Commandments on government grounds — violations similar to Rollins’ “proselytizing messages,” the plaintiffs argued.
Thompson found that Rollins “appears to exploit her position of authority to convey a religious message beyond mere holiday wishes and amounting to coercion.” She also found that Rollins’ “alienating language” contributed to a “culture and environment within the USDA which ostensibly universally conforms with the Secretary’s beliefs.”
The judge also noted Rollins’ use of pronouns like “we,” “us” and “our” when writing about aspects of the Christian faith, as well as her “failure to recognize other religious holidays.”
“Given the inclusion of first-person plural pronouns, there is no way of reading the challenged messages other than ascribing the Secretary’s particular religious view among all its recipients,” Thompson wrote.
In previous filings, the Trump administration argued that Rollins had not applied any coercive pressure through the emails because she merely shared her own personal views ahead of celebrating certain holidays.
The USDA did not immediately respond to a request for comment on Thursday’s ruling.
“I do use this platform, I believe in making disciples of all the nations,” Rollins told Trinity Broadcasting Network in September, referring to her position as agriculture secretary.
Thursday’s decision is the second ruling made against the USDA in California’s Northern District in as many months. In October, a federal judge issued a preliminary injunction against the agency’s mass-relocation plans, which federal employee unions said are an attempt to reduce the size of the agency’s workforce.