A federal appeals court ruled that the House’s passage of a government funding bill by proxy vote in 2022 had violated the Constitution because the chamber did not meet quorum requirements.
On Friday night, the conservative-majority 5th Circuit Court of Appeals found in a 9-8 decision that the House had unconstitutionally passed its appropriations bill four years ago, meaning Texas state officials are not required to implement a provision that provides protections for pregnant workers as outlined in the budget package.
Lawmakers in the Democratic-controlled chamber were allowed to approve their omnibus spending bill in December 2022 through proxy vote because of the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic — allowing them to reach quorum and pass the appropriations measure.
Texas state officials sued the Department of Justice and other federal agencies in 2023 to block implementation of the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, a measure in the appropriations bill that requires employers to provide “reasonable accommodations” for employees’ limitations due to pregnancy, childbirth or related medical conditions.
Trending
In May 2024, the federal government — still led by then-President Joe Biden — appealed a district court’s decision to block enforcement of the PWFA under the same quorum clause reasoning. The appeals court’s Friday decision upheld the previous decision using similar arguments.
The Constitution’s quorum clause indicates that lawmakers “must be present for quorum purposes — as the Supreme Court expressly held over 125 years ago, and as Congress has done ever since the Founding,” the court wrote in its ruling.
Judges representing the majority opinion said the rulemaking clause, which allows Congress to determine its own procedural guidelines, does not overrule the need to be physically present for quorum purposes.
U.S. Circuit Judge James Graves, an Obama appointee, said in his dissent that the concern of the judges in the majority with physical presence “shoehorns a much larger requirement” into the Constitution’s existing clause parameters. He also said Texas’ request to avoid enforcing the law was contradictory to the state’s acceptance of the rest of the appropriations package.
“Texas, having accepted the vast majority of the funds that Congress appropriated to it, now contends that the portion of the bill providing protections for pregnant women and workers violates the Quorum Clause,” Graves wrote.
He added: “Simply put, the majority’s decision is illogical, inexplicable, and invalid.”
The appeals court did not rule on the legality of proxy voting, nor did it invalidate other provisions within the appropriations package, limiting the scope to Texas’ ability to not enforce the PWFA.
Proxy voting has increasingly become a bipartisan issue for lawmakers — particularly after Rep. Anna Paulina Luna (R-Florida) and Rep. Brittany Pettersen (D-Colorado) introduced a bipartisan discharge petition in spring 2025 aimed at making it easier for new mothers to serve in Congress, though House Speaker Mike Johnson eventually killed the effort.
At a Thursday news conference, Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries said he’d support proxy voting for expectant mothers and new parents once Democrats retake control of the House in January. Pettersen this fall proposed giving members three months to vote by proxy, beginning before childbirth.
Friday’s ruling would likely not affect lawmakers’ recent propositions for proxy voting, as resolutions from members like Pettersen or Luna would not count such votes toward reaching a quorum.
The National Women’s Law Center said Friday’s ruling allows Texas to put pregnant workers in a perilous position.
“Only a few weeks ago voters nationwide sent a clear message that affordability and rising costs were their top priority, but this decision will only serve to increase economic uncertainty for women in Texas,” said Gaylynn Burroughs, the organization’s vice president for education and workplace justice.