Democrats tore into President Donald Trump’s nominee to lead the Navy over the treatment of sailors deployed to the Iran war, pressing him about suicide attempts and deteriorating conditions aboard U.S. warships in the Middle East.
During Hung Cao’s confirmation hearing for Navy secretary before the Senate Armed Services Committee, he defended the Navy’s handling of the incidents during the USS Abraham Lincoln strike group’s nearly 11-month deployment, telling Sen. Richard Blumenthal (D-Connecticut), “You see it as eight suicide attempts, I see it as eight suicide mitigations.”
Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand (D-New York) sharply rebuked him, accusing him of downplaying eight suicide attempts among sailors in the strike group by framing them as successful interventions by military mental health personnel.
“Please don’t call them attempted suicide mitigations,” Gillibrand said. “That is such an insult.”
Trending
Gillibrand challenged Cao’s account of one incident in which a sailor jumped overboard. Cao insisted the sailor had worn a life preserver and was trying to leave the service rather than kill himself.
“What was he trying to do? Swim to Guam?” Gillibrand asked.
Cao, a retired Navy captain who has served as acting secretary since April, cited his own deployments to Iraq, Afghanistan and Somalia when sticking up for his handling of sailors’ welfare.
“I have been in places that we get two [meals] a day and five bottles of water,” he said. “I understand what our sailors and Marines are going through, and I put mental health as a top … concern.”
Gillibrand pushed back on a statement from Cao in August when he argued that news reports were “dishonest” for casting troops as victims.
“I think your response is inhumane; I think it’s inadequate,” Gillibrand said. “I don’t think it understands the stress and strain that these men and women are under because of these poor conditions.”
The confrontation was among several heated exchanges during the contentious hearing, which offered senators a rare chance to publicly question a senior administration official about the war’s toll on the military.
Cao’s nomination already faced an unusual obstacle in that Congress must waive a federal law requiring former military officers to be separated from active duty for at least seven years before becoming a civilian service secretary. Cao, who retired in 2021, requires an exemption that Democrats could block through a filibuster.
The White House did not immediately respond to requests for comment on Cao’s hearing. A senior Pentagon official said in a statement that the department “looks forward to working with Congress throughout Acting Secretary Cao’s confirmation process.”
Other senators pressed Cao over reports of food shortages, contaminated water and deteriorating living conditions aboard deployed warships.
Sen. Mark Kelly (D-Arizona) cited reports of service members losing significant weight. Cao acknowledged that one destroyer, the USS Gonzalez, had only about a week’s worth of rations left, but disputed claims that sailors were being deprived of adequate food.
“It’s like my kids opening up the refrigerator door and saying, ‘There’s nothing in here,’” Cao said.
“Somebody doesn’t lose 45 pounds just because they don’t like the options,” Kelly shot back.
When Sen. Tammy Duckworth (D-Illinois) repeatedly pressed Cao over whether he had urged Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth to end the Iran war over its impact on naval readiness, Cao said his responsibility was to organize, train and equip the Navy.
“I cannot vote for you because you’re going to be another yes man,” Duckworth told him.
Senators criticized Cao over his handling of congressional oversight more broadly.
Sen. Jack Reed of Rhode Island, the panel’s top Democrat, rapped Cao for failing to notify Congress about the removal last month of the USS South Dakota’s three senior officers over a grounding or near-grounding incident.
“We need to have details promptly, and you have to do that — and you didn’t do that,” Reed said.
Cao acknowledged what he called a “near-mishap” and, in an exchange with Sen. Tim Kaine (D-Virginia), conceded there were “no excuses” for failing to notify Congress. He said the officers were relieved from duty for failing to meet Navy standards, but he defended withholding details to protect their privacy and future careers. He said the incident is still under investigation.
“I just didn’t want it to be blasted out on Navy Times again,” he said.
The criticism didn’t come from just one side of the aisle. Sen. Mike Rounds (R-South Dakota) voiced frustration with the Trump administration for excluding Democrats from classified briefings on the defense budget, warning that the partisan approach could jeopardize congressional support for additional defense funding.
“Pretty tough to ask all of my colleagues to support that if they’re not even invited in to hear the information in the first place,” Rounds said.
Cao acknowledged the need for bipartisan cooperation, and in a later exchange, he committed not to hold single-party briefings.
“National defense is not a partisan issue,” Cao said. “This is a bipartisan issue, and so I give you my commitment that I will work with both sides.”
Senators also questioned Cao about the war’s financial costs and the consequences for readiness elsewhere in the force.
Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Massachusetts) asked Cao how much the Navy was spending each day to maintain its blockade of Iranian ports.
“I do not know the daily cost,” he replied.
Warren cited an independent estimate of $32.5 million per day, or about $1 billion per month, and challenged Cao over his inability to provide a figure. When she questioned him about the cost of damage from Iranian strikes on the U.S. naval base in Bahrain, home to the Navy’s Fifth Fleet, he again had no answer.
“We’re still making all the assessments because it’s a non-permissive area for us to go,” Cao said.
Warren cited an estimate of at least $400 million in damage and criticized the administration
“Trump’s war is costing taxpayers billions,” she said. “It is harming our readiness, all while driving up prices here at home. So it’s no surprise that the Trump administration doesn’t want to reveal the total cost of this war.”