A federal judge on Friday declined to extend restrictions on taxpayer-funded political ads that highlighted President Donald Trump, saying that the challengers had not proved the ads could cause further harm now that the midterms are over.
U.S. District Judge Jennifer Rochon wrote that arguments by the candidates and political groups who brought the suit were “too speculative and non-imminent” to justify continued emergency relief.
“Supporting candidates in future elections and the speculative possibility of campaigning in hypothetical elections with unknown surrounding circumstances are not ‘emergency situations’ presently before the Court,” Rochon, a Joe Biden appointee, wrote.
Rochon’s ruling keeps the lawsuit alive, leaving open the legal questions surrounding the administration’s use of public money to cut the ads.
Trending
The New York-based case challenges a $20 million advertising contract that drew on money Congress had appropriated for border security. Common Cause; a Democratic Alabama state House candidate, Robert Hunter; SEIU Local 32BJ and its affiliated political action committee filed the lawsuit in October.
On Oct. 14, Rochon quickly blocked the ads through the midterms, and in a later ruling, she barred three new ads from airing, including one featuring Trump promising U.S. citizens $5,000 if Republicans won the elections.
On Friday, she denied the plaintiffs’ latest request to indefinitely block the placements, rejecting their argument that future broadcasts would hurt their preferred candidates in elections to come. In their earlier requests, she said, the plaintiffs focused on the November election.
“But circumstances are different now. Hunter lost the election for Alabama House District 28,” she wrote. “The November 3, 2026 elections to which SEIU 32BJ and Empire PAC previously pointed have also now concluded.”
Although she denied the plaintiffs’ emergency request, the decision also rejected the administration’s argument that the election’s conclusion meant the case should be dismissed outright. Future elections could come and go before the courts have time to rule on whether the spending is legal, she wrote.
The administration continues to defend its conduct, Rochon noted, and has not canceled the contract or expressed any “intent to stop running the advertisements.”
“Likewise, there is a reasonable expectation that the challenged advertisements will continue to be aired,” Rochon wrote.
The pro-administration ads are facing three separate legal challenges.
While the New York case takes issue with the government purchasing the spots, another complaint by the Democratic National Convention in D.C. alleges that the government unlawfully used public funds and paid staffers to produce the video and social media ads. Another federal judge heard arguments from the DNC and administration lawyers on Thursday, though it’s unclear when a ruling will be handed down in that case.
The third case, filed in D.C. by the Democratic Party of Wisconsin, concerns how the ads impacted a candidate for Wisconsin state treasurer.