The Washington Sun

Main Navigation

Subscribe Log in
  • Newsletters
    • Sign up for our newsletters
    • The Washington Sun newsletter
    • Afternoon Sun
    • Metro
    • Sign up for Dana Milbank’s newsletter
    • Sign up for Matt K. Lewis’ newsletter
  • Weather
  • Campaigns
    • 2026 Election
    • 2028 Election
    • Democrats
    • Republicans
    • Influence
  • Congress
    • House
    • Senate
  • Metro
    • Latest in Metro
    • Tom Sietsema
  • Sports
    • Latest in Sports
    • All-DMV High School
  • Policy
    • Administration
    • Defense
    • Energy & Environment
    • Immigration
    • Economy
    • Health
    • Foreign Policy
    • Housing
    • Technology
  • National
    • Legal
    • U.S. News
  • Perspectives
    • Latest Perspectives
    • Dana Milbank
    • Matt K. Lewis
    • Features
    • Forums
  • Podcast
    • Washington Sun Cast • Episode List
    • Milbank & Lewis • Episode List
  • Who Are We?
    • About The Washington Sun
    • Events
    • Work for us
    • Press Releases
    • Support FAQ
  • Follow Us
    • X (Twitter)
    • Bluesky
    • LinkedIn
    • Instagram
    • TikTok
    • YouTube
Subscribe
Log in

Support independent journalism. Subscribe for $50 for your first year. Limited time.

Immigration

Trump’s Call to End Birthright Citizenship Raises a Lot of Legal Questions

Even among Republicans.

Donald Trump speaks along the southern border.

Donald Trump said he would try to end birthright citizenship through executive action. Evan Vucci/AP

By Casey Murray

December 12, 2024 05:00 a.m.

  • Email
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • Copy
    Link copied

Donald Trump is bringing back an abandoned idea from his first term: ending birthright citizenship. Republicans in Congress aren’t sure he can do it.

“Birthright citizenship is absurd the way we’ve applied it,” Sen. Ron Johnson said. “I don’t think many people think that can be ended by executive action, though, unfortunately.”

Trump said he plans to end birthright citizenship on day one, in an interview with NBC News. But he himself alluded to some legal challenges. He said he’d end it through executive action “if we can” but also that it might “have to go back to the people.”

He floated the idea initially during his first term, but it didn’t go anywhere. Some Republicans at the time were critical of the idea, including former Speaker Paul Ryan. Now, many of the Republicans NOTUS spoke to were open to it, even if they acknowledged that the legal ground is murky.

Trending

  • House Democrats

    Dana Milbank: These Are 36 Fights the Dems Can Win in 2027

  • DC: Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin Testifies B

    Milbank & Lewis Podcast: Mullin fumbles and Musk tries to disown MAGA

  • KirstenDavies

    Top Defense Official Purchased Stock in Defense Companies

  • Trinity Rodman NWSL Final 1

    The Spirit Suffers Another Heartbreak, Losing 2-1 in NWSL Final

“I support ending it by whatever means can be effective,” Sen. Ted Cruz said, though on whether Congress would have to change the 14th Amendment, said, “That’s actually a disputed legal question, and there are serious scholarly arguments on both sides.”

Sen. Eric Schmitt said he’d have to look at the language of any executive action on the matter. “I think we ought to take a look at everything right now,” Schmitt said. “It’s just fundamentally been abused. The American people have had enough of it, and so we’ll see.”

The last real challenge to birthright citizenship came in 1890. The 14th Amendment says, “All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.” The Supreme Court has since supported the idea that any person born in the U.S. is considered a citizen.

Conservatives who want to challenge the amendment focus on the phrase “jurisdiction thereof,” arguing that it creates some wiggle room around who is under the jurisdiction of the U.S. government.

Though that’s a wobbly argument, Adam Winkler, a professor at UCLA and an expert in constitutional law, said.

“There is no doubt that the child of an undocumented immigrant born in the United States is a citizen. It’s clear that they are subject to the jurisdiction of the United States, that is to say that they are subject to the governmental power of the United States,” Winkler said. “Their argument depends on a definition of ‘jurisdiction’ that has no basis in American law.”

Trump didn’t provide any more specifics on how he intends to implement the idea, but previous reporting indicates the administration could change the requirements for applying for documents like passports, which would effectively bar people from being able to prove their citizenship. That would quickly meet legal challenges.

“Any attempt by the president or by Congress to limit birthright citizenship is unconstitutional,” Cody Wofsy, deputy director of the ACLU Immigrants’ Rights Project, said. “Any such action would be met by litigation in court, and hopefully it would be blocked.”

Josh Blackman, a professor at the South Texas College of Law Houston, told NOTUS that there are some new ideas the Trump team could try out, namely around the idea that the U.S. is being “invaded.”

“There’s a part of the Constitution called the invasion clause, which people don’t focus on, but it’s become very relevant,” he said. “Trump declares an invasion, which he will probably do on day one, and says, ‘Well, if you’re the child of an invading force, you’re not a citizen.’ In other words, you’re no different than a belligerent army that’s attacking us.”

Blackman didn’t necessarily think that argument would be successful but said he thinks it’s one the Trump administration is likely to try out. Some Republican-led states have also tried to use invasion rhetoric to justify taking immigration matters into their own hands, like Texas Gov. Greg Abbott.

“I think that the children of illegal aliens are citizens. I think that’s the best reading of the 14th Amendment,” Blackman said, but “the invasion argument, though, does throw in a wrinkle.”

Wofsy said that while conservatives might call migration an “invasion,” it falls short of any official definition that indicates another country has organized a takeover of U.S. soil.

“There’s not a lot of case law on it, but what case law there is is clear that just talking about what one views as too much immigration just doesn’t count as an invasion,” he said. “Invasion is about organized military incursion into U.S. territory, and that’s something that is simply not happening right now.”

If Trump’s executive actions fail, he could try to pressure Congress to take up the issue and amend the Constitution. That’s an effort that would surely fail, given slim majorities in the House and Senate.

However, few were willing to totally write off the possibility of Trump finding a way to change birthright citizenship.

“Some people may say that that’s not realistic because it is illegal, and it’s not legally within the norms, but I think what we know is that the Trump administration is more than willing to break the law, and they have appointed to the Supreme Court that will allow him to break the law,” Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez said. “Removing and stripping birthright citizenship, if he wants to do it, he has a pattern of behavior doing illegal things and saying, ‘Well, what are you going to do about it?’”

“Don’t bet your house on the future rulings of the Supreme Court,” Winkler said.

—
Casey Murray is a NOTUS reporter and an Allbritton Journalism Institute fellow.

Author

2023_Murray-Casey_MUG-500px.png Casey Murray is a former NOTUS reporter and Allbritton Journalism Institute fellow.

The Latest

  • Trinity Rodman NWSL Final 1

    The Spirit Suffers Another Heartbreak, Losing 2-1 in NWSL Final

  • Trump

    Trump Signals Further Interest in Working With Democrats on ‘TrumpCare’

  • Light shines on the U.S. Capitol dome on Capitol Hill in Washington.

    Fifth Circuit Upholds Texas’ Block on Enforcing a Federal Pregnant Workers Law

  • Elizabeth Warren

    Trump Says He’ll Work With Democrats to Cap Credit Card Interest Rates

  • DonaldTrumpAI

    White House Limits Federal Contractors’ Ability to Respond to Democratic-Led Investigations

Welcome back to The Washington Sun!

You can always update your profile and newsletters preferences on the My Account page.

Manage account settings

Welcome to
The Washington Sun

Subscribe to maintain unlimited access to independent journalism covering Washington's people, politics and power.

Continue to checkout ↗
  • About The Washington Sun
  • Work for us
  • Terms of Use
  • Subscription Agreement Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Your CA Privacy Rights
  • Support FAQ
  • Contact us

© 2026.0 NOTUS MEDIA, LLC