A bipartisan permitting reform deal is poised to sail through the Senate with the support of nearly all Republicans and more than a handful of Democrats. The Democrats who aren’t supporting it are asking: Why didn’t their colleagues wait until they were in power?
Many Senate Democrats have been frustrated by the carefully controlled process around the bill, which was negotiated by Sens. Sheldon Whitehouse (D-Rhode Island), Mike Lee (R-Utah), Shelley Moore Capito (R-West Virginia) and Martin Heinrich (D-New Mexico).
In a floor speech Tuesday, Sen. Jeff Merkley (D-Oregon) called the amendment process “bogus as hell.”
“It is all pretense,” he said. “This is ramming through in an authoritarian fashion a bill that has major consequences with not a single hearing in the House, not a single hearing here in the Senate. That’s wrong.”
Trending
The co-sponsors negotiated some changes to the bill, which would reshape the way federal energy projects are built and make changes to several longstanding environmental laws. Those tweaks addressed some concerns from Democrats that the legislation could undermine tribal sovereignty and threaten sacred sites.
They also pledged to vote against other amendments, including an effort led by Sen. Adam Schiff (D-California) to strike a whole section of the bill that tribal leaders spoke out against.
A spokesperson for Schiff said the senator is pushing for the consideration of his amendment through a floor vote, adding that the change already has the support of two-thirds of the Democratic caucus.
The urgent process to pass reforms that have been on the agenda for years has left many Democrats wondering why their colleagues are pushing to pass the bill under Republican majorities — and whether Democrats are abdicating leverage in doing so.
“I think that a deal that can be negotiated with the Democratic Senate and House is going to be far more favorable than a deal that is negotiated with a Republican trifecta,” Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-New York) told The Washington Sun.
Tribal concerns, data center issues and the fact that the Trump administration is backing the deal make her skeptical of the legislation. “I disagree with the assessment that this is the best that can be done and that if it’s not done now, it’ll never be done,” she said.
Sen. Cory Booker (D-New Jersey), who voted against the legislation during procedural votes, told The Sun there are a “whole bunch of amendments” that would get him to support the bill, but some aren’t being considered.
Booker said he liked many parts of the legislation, but wanted to see stronger protections against “the corruption of the Trump administration” and other “common sense” amendments.
“I hate to see it undermined by some of the things in there that just are really difficult to swallow,” he said.
The bill lost some support from Senate Democrats who objected to the way it would change longstanding environmental laws and the National Historic Preservation Act. Sen. Maria Cantwell (D-Washington) held a press conference Tuesday with Prairie Band Potawatomi, Oneida and Yakama leaders and the brand Patagonia to oppose the bill over tribal and environmental concerns.
Cantwell said the bill came to the Senate floor “without much notice and debate,” and that it hasn’t gotten the attention it deserves.
“Congress is being asked to vote on a sweeping proposal that would rewrite some of these important environmental laws. And as written, I think these provisions are certainly very dangerous,” she said.
Democrats who support the bill argue that permitting reform is necessary for a clean energy transition to take hold, and point to modeling that shows the bill would reduce climate-warming emissions and save communities money on energy bills.
Affordability, and the role it played for Democrats in the midterm elections, could buoy support for the bill as it clears Senate votes and makes its way to the House.
“I think the House realizes how powerful this bill is,” Sen. Alan Armstrong (R-Oklahoma), who made permitting reform his main priority during his time in the Senate, told The Sun. He added that the bill would be a “tough thing to vote against” for members who have highlighted affordability concerns.
House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries initially expressed concern about the bill, but late last week said at the Majority Democrats conference in Denver that he was committed to passing the legislation as part of efforts to “decisively address the affordability crisis.”
Jeffries spoke as protesters heckled him from below the stage. One shouted, “You better not let a single Democrat vote for BAAJA,” referring to the permitting reform bill. “This is your first big test on climate. Why should we trust you when you are in the pocket of corporations?”
But House Democrats focused on environmental issues said they are hoping for more changes to the bill, or to try again next session.
California Rep. Jared Huffman said he would push for changes when the bill comes to the House, calling the bill the “most sweeping energy and environmental bill in decades.” Huffman has taken issue with provisions that change environmental laws including the Clean Water Act and the Endangered Species Act, along with the ways the bill would limit the ability of communities to fight projects in court.
“The rationale behind this narrative that this will be the only permitting reform opportunity ever is so shallow that it just shocks me people are saying it,” he said.
Rep. Chellie Pingree (D-Maine), part of the Sustainable Energy and Environment Coalition in the House, said she has concerns about environmental issues and tribal consultation but is open to looking at amendments.
That coalition has said that while the bill includes “important policies” that could unlock clean energy and reduce utility bills, it could limit environmental laws too much.
“Everyone agrees that we need some permitting reform,” Pingree said. “But this bill seems like it didn’t have sufficient House consultation, and there are just a lot of problems that could be repaired.”
With support from President Donald Trump and House Speaker Mike Johnson’s expectation that the bill will have the votes, Democrats’ concerns may not get much consideration.