The Washington Sun

Main Navigation

Subscribe Log in
  • Newsletters
    • Sign up for our newsletters
    • The Washington Sun newsletter
    • Afternoon Sun
    • Metro
    • Sign up for Dana Milbank’s newsletter
    • Sign up for Matt K. Lewis’ newsletter
  • Weather
  • Campaigns
    • 2026 Election
    • 2028 Election
    • Democrats
    • Republicans
    • Influence
  • Congress
    • House
    • Senate
  • Metro
    • Latest in Metro
    • Tom Sietsema
  • Sports
    • Latest in Sports
    • All-DMV High School
  • Policy
    • Administration
    • Defense
    • Energy & Environment
    • Immigration
    • Economy
    • Health
    • Foreign Policy
    • Housing
    • Technology
  • National
    • Legal
    • U.S. News
  • Perspectives
    • Latest Perspectives
    • Dana Milbank
    • Matt K. Lewis
    • Features
    • Forums
  • Podcast
    • Washington Sun Cast • Episode List
    • Milbank & Lewis • Episode List
    • Listen on Apple Podcasts
    • Listen on Spotify
    • Watch on Youtube
  • Who Are We?
    • About The Washington Sun
    • Events
    • Work for us
    • Press Releases
    • Support FAQ
  • Follow Us
    • X (Twitter)
    • Bluesky
    • LinkedIn
    • Instagram
    • TikTok
    • YouTube
Subscribe
Log in

Support independent journalism. Subscribe for $50 for your first year. Limited time.

Legal

Judge Dismisses John Brennan’s Lawsuit Over Criminal Probes

The former CIA director wanted a court to order the Justice Department to preserve records so he could later challenge any criminal charges.

Trump Russia Probe

Former CIA Director John Brennan, the target of multiple federal probes, sued the Justice Department in July. (Pablo Martinez Monsivais/AP)

By Derek Hawkins

October 15, 2026 04:15 p.m.

Updated: October 16, 2026 11:26 a.m.

  • Email
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • Copy
    Link copied

A federal judge on Thursday threw out former CIA Director John Brennan’s lawsuit demanding that the Justice Department preserve records in its broad investigation into claims that he and other national security officials conspired to undermine President Donald Trump.

U.S. District Judge Jia Cobb ruled that Brennan had raised “deeply concerning” allegations about being politically targeted by the Trump administration, but said he hadn’t shown that the Justice Department was failing to hold onto records that might help his defense against potential criminal charges.

“Instead, he is concerned that Defendants may not be complying with their preservation obligations based on the conduct of certain government officials in other cases,” Cobb wrote.

Brennan, the target of multiple federal probes, sued the Justice Department in July, seeking a court order requiring investigators to keep a broad range of records that he said he may need to defend himself.

Trending

  • Stephen Miller

    Inside Stephen Miller’s Fixation on Minnesota’s Somalis

  • Jon Tester

    Democrats Won a Big Race in Montana. Why Do They Have Regrets?

  • Congress House Returns

    Democrats Are Reviewing a Plan to Investigate Corporate America

  • Trump Carter

    Trump Orders the DOJ to Investigate Democrats’ Oversight Plans

His lawsuit says he plans to contest any prosecution that arises from the DOJ’s probes as vindictive and selective and that internal records and communications will be critical in establishing that in court.

The former CIA director alleged that the president — who has repeatedly called for him to be investigated and charged — had singled him out in retaliation for his role in investigating the Trump campaign’s ties to the Russian government in 2016.

Cobb, an appointee of President Joe Biden, signaled that she took that aspect of Brennan’s case seriously, saying that “if he was eventually able to prove those allegations true, that would certainly suggest that his potential prosecution is vindictive.”

At this point, Brennan is not facing enough harm to establish he has a right to bring the lawsuit, the ruling says.

“Even taking all of Brennan’s allegations to be truthful at this stage,” the judge wrote, “the injury he alleges is simply too attenuated from the actions he seeks to enjoin to warrant a finding of standing here.”

After publication, Brennan’s lawyers, Ken Wainstein and Dan Gelber, said in a statement that the dismissal was “based on the technical legal issue of standing, not on the merits of Director Brennan’s claim that the Justice Department is using the criminal justice system to target and investigate him for politically vindictive reasons.”

“With this lawsuit, Director Brennan has served notice that the government’s conduct and its document preservation will be carefully scrutinized in the event of any future indictment,” they said. “Director Brennan will continue to vigorously defend himself against these baseless investigations, and he will challenge any attempt to use the criminal justice system for personal and political retribution.”

The judge’s order grants a motion to dismiss by the government. DOJ lawyers argued that Brennan lacked standing to bring the lawsuit, calling his claims “speculative.” Brennan, they said in court papers, was asking the district court to take the “unprecedented step of managing potential discovery in a hypothetical future criminal case in Florida.”

Brennan contended in the complaint that the Trump administration’s alleged mishandling of records in other unrelated cases created a “very real risk” that he might not be able to access records that could be useful in a future defense.

He cited numerous examples, including the Justice Department’s alleged failure to retain records in its failed prosecution of another Trump adversary, New York Attorney General Letitia James.

Cobb said such allegations were “damnable and unbecoming of any officer of the federal government” but not connected to Brennan’s lawsuit.

“There is no allegation anywhere in the complaint from which the Court can draw the plausible inference that Defendants are actively failing to preserve records that would be relevant to Brennan’s vindictive- or selective-prosecution defenses, to the extent such records exist,” she wrote.

Brennan is among several Obama-era officials targeted by the Justice Department in a “grand conspiracy” investigation widely viewed as an attempt to exact vengeance on Trump’s perceived political enemies.

The effort, run out of south Florida, focuses on whether law enforcement and intelligence officials violated Trump’s civil rights through investigations that started with the Trump-Russia probe in 2016.

Brennan’s possible indictment has been rumored for months.

Last month, one of Brennan’s lawyers disclosed in court papers that a Trump administration official told him there were “multiple ‘viable’ grand jury investigations” underway, including “a ‘far-reaching’ investigation in Fort Pierce that includes ‘issues at Mar-a-Lago and beyond.’”

Author

Derek Hawkins Derek Hawkins is a reporter at The Washington Sun.

Contributor

Jose Pagliery, NOTUS Reporter Jose Pagliery is a reporter at The Washington Sun.

The Latest

  • Trump Carter

    Trump Orders the DOJ to Investigate Democrats’ Oversight Plans

  • President Donald Trump with Dana White

    Trump Announces His Next Press Secretary Pick: Dana White

  • East Potomac Tree Cutting

    Judge Appoints Special Master to East Potomac Park Case Probe

  • Trae Young AP - 26311101408656

    The Duality of Trae Young

  • Election 2026 California Noncitizen Voting

    DOJ Drops Its Bid to Force California to Segregate Disputed Ballots

Welcome back to The Washington Sun!

You can always update your profile and newsletters preferences on the My Account page.

Manage account settings

Welcome to
The Washington Sun

Subscribe to maintain unlimited access to independent journalism covering Washington's people, politics and power.

Continue to checkout ↗
  • About The Washington Sun
  • Work for us
  • Terms of Use
  • Subscription Agreement Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Your CA Privacy Rights
  • Support FAQ
  • Contact us

© 2026.0 NOTUS MEDIA, LLC