AUSTIN — James Talarico is projected to become Texas’ first statewide elected Democrat in more than three decades, defeating state Attorney General Ken Paxton in the most watched and most expensive Senate race in history.
The victory is a landmark moment for the Democratic Party, which has spent years attempting to wrestle control of Texas away from Republicans and predicting that the state’s changing demographics would eventually allow it to do so.
While Democrats were optimistic going into Tuesday evening, when it became clear Talarico would win, the energy at the election night watch party with the candidate was palpable. Selena played as Talarico took to the stage for an acceptance speech, in which he told a cheering crowd that the lesson of the campaign was to “always bet on the underdog.”
“In this race, we went up against our own Goliaths,” Talarico said. “David wasn’t as big or as strong as Goliath. He didn’t have as many weapons, but he had hope. He had faith, and he had a slingshot. You were my slingshot. The people of Texas were my slingshot.”
Trending
He added: “This win is for every Texan who ever wondered if anyone was listening. I heard you.”
The auditorium he spoke in was full of hundreds of people wearing cowboy hats and holding signs. Many were so excited by his win that they cried.
During a concession speech given late Tuesday, Paxton said he’d be “praying” for Talarico. Paxton said he was grateful for “the opportunity to try to do the best I could to do good for Texas” during his 12 years as the state’s attorney general.
“I love Texas, I’ll always love Texas. We will still fight for this place,” Paxton said. “We’ve had a difficult night tonight across the country, but it’s not over.”
Throughout the campaign, Talarico, a two-term state representative, merged messages of faith and populism. He made a case to independent and Republican voters who were turned off by the Trump administration and Paxton that he could be a candidate for all kinds of Texans.
Talarico leaned on hometown nostalgia. He appeared alongside country singers Kacey Musgraves and The Chicks, and branded himself with “Friday Night Lights”-inspired messaging. He touted endorsements by members of the Bush family and Thomas J. Henry, a well-known personal injury attorney who backed Paxton during the Republican primary.
“I am tired of us being divided into teams, left versus right, blue versus red, urban versus rural,” Talarico said during a town hall hosted by CNN and Jubilee Media in October. “Because the truth is, we’re all on the same team.”
Talarico consistently polled ahead of Paxton throughout the race. In the election’s final weeks, Republican donors, including Elon Musk, began dumping hundreds of millions of dollars into the race to support Paxton.
“James took on all the slings and arrows for the team, forcing unprecedented amounts of money to be spent against him, and not elsewhere in Texas or across the country,” Democratic state Rep. John Bucy said during Talarico’s election night party.
The Sen. Chuck Schumer-aligned Senate Majority PAC waded into the race in September, when it began an advertising blitz against Paxton. Home to 20 different media markets, Texas is among the most expensive states to campaign in, and the super PAC had hoped to focus spending on smaller, cheaper states, The New York Times reported.
Talarico was able to pull off the upset in part because Paxton was weighed down with his own baggage.
Over the course of the campaign, Paxton faced criticism over unforced errors: Leaked audio in which he was critical of his own party repeatedly became a focal point, and in October, The Wall Street Journal published footage that showed Paxton partying in Dubai with U.S. fugitives.
His wife, who filed for divorce “on biblical grounds” last year, appeared in an ad encouraging voters to support Republican candidates, though she did not name Paxton. Incumbent Republican Sen. John Cornyn, whom Paxton defeated in a runoff election, declined to offer his endorsement. Paxton’s 2023 impeachment (and acquittal) by his own party, haunted the campaign.
Still, Paxton tried to rile his base by painting Talarico as too liberal for the state.
“If we lose Texas, we lose America,” was a regular refrain at Paxton’s campaign rallies.
At 37 years old, Talarico will be the youngest member of the Senate. He appealed broadly to younger voters at a time when skepticism toward the gerontocracy, and entrenched Washington politicians, was on the rise.
Talarico pledged to tackle issues related to affordability, education access and the growing class divide once sworn in. During his acceptance speech, he rebuked the “blood sport” that he believes politics have become and lamented that ideological divides have ruined friendships and families.
“Love can turn an enemy into a friend. Love can turn a campaign into a movement,” Talarico said. “Love can heal what’s broken in America.”
—
Editor’s Note: This story has been updated with additional reporting.